Results are available are available here.
Ontology Alignment Evaluation Initiative - OAEI-2014 Campaign

Benchmark test

The goal of the benchmark test is to offer a set of tests which are wide in feature coverage, progressive and stable. It serves the purpose of evaluating the strength and weakness of matchers (by being progressive and wide coverage) and measuring the progress of matchers (by being stable and reusable over the years).

Expected results of matchers are alignments between the named and properties in the namespace of the ontologies. Instances are not in the reference alignments.

Data sets

The benchmark test library consists of data sets that are built from reference ontologies of different sizes and from different domains. The bibliographic ontology described here has been the main reference ontology since the beginning of OAEI campaigns. Since OAEI 2011, we use new systematically generated benchmarks, based on other ontologies than the bibliographic one.

As for previous campaigns, Benchmark test suites (or data sets) have been generated from seed ontologies [1]. This year, in addition to the bibliographic ontology, we have used two ontologies from the domotic domain:

The usual bibliography ontology which concerns bibliographic references and is inspired freely from BibTeX;
COSE is the Casas Ontology for Smart Environments
DogOnto is an ontology describing aspects of intelligent domotic environments.
The following table summarizes the information about ontologies' sizes.

Test set biblio cose dog
ontology size
classes+prop 97 196 842
instances 112 34 0
entities 209 235 848
triples 1332 690 10625

Testing your tool

It is not necessary anymore to download the data sets (it has always been better to get it on the web). The SEALS platform will provide the data sets.

Participants can test their tools using the standard benchmark dataset described above, which can be downloaded here. They can enforce testing with a subset of data sets built with reference ontologies used in previous campaigns, which are stored in the Test Data Repository accessible through the SEALS portal. Note that two of these data sets were built based on the same reference ontologies (biblio and finance) which will be used in OAEI 2014.

All those data sets maintain the structure explained in the Example of a complete benchmark data set section, and testing with those data sets can be done by using the SEALS client. This client iterates over tests in a data set whose identifier is provided as a parameter. In all cases, the ontologies found in the data set directories are matched (either against the ontology found in 101/onto.rdf, or both ontologies to match are in the same directory). The resulting alignments must be outputted in the alignment format. They are placed in a local directory given also as a parameter to the client.

The identifiers of data sets for testing with the SEALS client are given below:

Biblio data set

Cose data set

Dog data set

We encourage you to use the Alignment API for manipulating and generating your alignments, and, in particular, for computing evaluation of your results.


Contact address is Jerome : Euzenat # inria : fr


[1] Jérôme Euzenat, Maria Roşoiu, Cássia Trojahn dos Santos. Ontology matching benchmarks: generation, stability, and discriminability, Journal of web semantics 21:30-48, 2013 [DOI:10.1016/j.websem.2013.05.002]